Can I refactor out an "unused" $request variable in a controller? - php

Let's say I'm building a small application, where a small part of it is responsible for sending an email when a contact form is submitted. I only want to do that if the contact form passes some simple validation.
In the following controller the ContactRequest $request parameter is unused inside the method, although Laravel used the type-hinting to automatically apply the ContactRequest logic to the request.
Is it possible to achieve the same thing without leaving an unused variable in the controller method?
// Route
Route::post( 'contact', 'PageController#submitContactForm' );
// PageController
public function submitContactForm( ContactRequest $request ) {
sendContactFormEmail();
return redirect()->back();
}
// ContactRequest
public function authorize() {
return hasNotSubmittedContactFormRecently();
}
public function rules() {
return [ 'message' => 'required' ];
}

Yes, you can write your controller method like so:
// PageController
public function submitContactForm()
{
app()->make(ContactRequest::class);
sendContactFormEmail();
return redirect()->back();
}
and it will have same effect. However for me it's better to use it as you used it before.
Also probably you somehow use data you receive, so it might be more reasonable to use it like this:
sendContactFormEmail($request);
instead of probably injecting request into sendContactFormEmail method.

Related

Call to a member function fails() on array in update() method

In my method update() has some block of error conditions Call to a member function failed on array precisely that checks if $validations fails. I noticed that all the store() and updated() methods work correctly without the need for the conditional block. I just thought it would be nice to insert these conditions.
namespace App\Http\Controllers;
use App\Http\Requests\HunterRequest;
use Illuminate\Http\Request;
use App\Models\HunterModel;
class HunterController extends Controller {
public function store(Request $request)
{
$validations = $request->validate();
if ($validations->fails()){
return redirect()->back();
}
HunterModel::create($validations);
return redirect()->to('/');
}
public function update(Request $request, $id)
{
$validations = $request->validate();
if ($validations->fails()){ // Call to a member function fails() on array
return redirect()->back();
}
HunterModel::where('id',$id)->update($validations);
return redirect()->to('/');
}
}
$request->validate() expects an array of validation rules to validate the incoming request data against. You're not currently supplying anything so aren't actually performing any validation.
If validation is successful, the return value of that call will be an array of validated data, it is not an object and so doesn't have a fails() method (or any methods for that matter).
// $validations is an array
$validations = $request->validate([
'field' => ['required'],
]);
If validation is not successful, Laravel will automatically redirect back to the caller sending all failuer errors messages.
Therefore, the following lines are redundant and should be removed as Laravel will handle failure scenarios for you:
if ($validations->fails()){
return redirect()->back();
}
you are using validate method for the validation logic, this method return an array ...
you should use make method to check validation's fails
$validator = Validator::make($request->all(), [
'smoeFiled' => 'required|.....',
]);
you should also provide the validator with validation rules.
see Laravel doc for more details.

Adding Parameter From Controller to Validation Request

I want to devide my controller to several service layer, validation layer, and logical layer.
But I got stuck when I want to send new variable to validation request, my schenario is, if there is a new sent it indicates for new data, and if new variable is not exists it indicates it's updating data.
Here is my Controller:
public function store(AlbumRequest $request, AlbumService $service)
{
$request->add(['new' => true])
try{
$service->store($request);
return redirect(route('admin.web.album.index'));
}catch(\Exception $err){
return back()->withInput()->with('error',$err->getMessage());
}
}
Here is my Request
class AlbumRequest extends FormRequest
{
public function rules()
{
dd($this->request->get('new')
}
}
I want to catch variable I have sent from Controller to Request. How to do that?
Thank you.
You can add new parameter in request from controller like that
$request->merge(array('new' => true));
before your request reaches your controller , it has to go through AlbumRequest class . so you have to merge that field in AlbumRequest class by using method prepareForValidation :
protected function prepareForValidation()
{
$this->merge([
'new' => true,
]);
}
add this method in your AlbumRequest class and see if it works
I am afraid you cannot do that because the incoming form request is validated before the controller method is called. Now if you want to know whether the request is for creating something new or updating something, you can do it by accessing the route parameters and method type
public function rules()
{
$rules = [
'something' => 'required',
];
if (in_array($this->method(), ['PUT', 'PATCH'])) {
//it is an edit request
//you can also access router parameter here, $this->route()->parameter('other thing');
$rules['somethingelse'] = [
'required',
];
}
return $rules;
}
You can enter the requested class as URL params.
class AlbumRequest extends FormRequest
{
public function rules()
{
dd(request()->get('new')
}
}

Newbie question about controller and request in Laravel in my case

I am new in Laravel, what I try to achieve is very simple thing, I would like to use FormRequest provided by Laravel to do validation of the request, but I encounter some puzzles (which I am sure is easy things to solve if you are experienced in Laravel).
Here is what I tried:
I have route maps to controller:
Route::put('user/{name}', 'UserController#show');
I can get the name parameter in show function:
class UserController {
public function show($name)
{
// validtion rules to apply
...
}
}
I have validation rules to apply to the request, so I decided to create form request by php artisan make:request ShowRequest, which creates the form request class:
class ShowRequest extends FormRequest {
public function authorize()
{
return true;
}
public function rules()
{
return [
// my validation rules here
];
}
}
Since I have above request class, so I refactored the show function in controller to receive the ShowRequest .
class UserController {
public function show(ShowRequest $request)
{
// now I don't need validtion rules in this function
// but how can I access the 'name' parameter now
...
}
}
I have two questions to ask:
Inside the refactored show function, how can I now access the route parameter name ?
If we forget about the parameter is a name (please don't focus on what to validate for name, imaging it is an object or value to validate in general). How to add custom logic for handling validation error instead of using Laravel default behaviour. I want to inject code like dummy code below:
if (!$validator->pass())
{
//my custom code for handling validation failure
}
Where to put my custom code for handling validation error now? I mean I don't know where to have this logic, in controller? in the request class? how?
You still can add the parameter $name in the show() method of your controller as it's part of the routed url more than the validated form/data. (recommanded)
class UserController {
public function show(ShowRequest $request, $name)
{
//...
}
}
You can also access it from the request object
class UserController {
public function show(ShowRequest $request)
{
$request->input('name');
}
}
As for the error messages (not the exception) you can add the messages() method to your ShowRequest::class
class ShowRequest extends FormRequest
{
/**
* #return array
*/
public function messages()
{
return [
'name.required' => 'The name is required',
'name.numeric' => 'The name must be a number',
//...
];
}
}
If you instead need to validate that the name catched by the route is only composed of letter OR really exists as a field in your DB (like a slug of a post) you need to add some validation in your route declaration.
Setup a route that catches request only if it is composed of letters.
Route::get('/user/{name}', 'Controller#show')->where(['name' => '[a-z]+']);
Setup a route that catches request only if the "name" exists in DB:
User.php
Class User //..
{
/**
* Get the route key for the model.
*
* #return string
*/
public function getRouteKeyName()
{
return 'name';
}
}
web.php
//
Route::get('/user/{user:name}', 'Controller#show');
And adapt your controller to take a user directly
class UserController {
public function show(ShowRequest $request, User $user)
{
//...
}
}
You can access the values of the Form Request using this
$validated = $request->validated();
The $validated will have all the values which had been validated by the FormRequest.
To answer your second question, if you want to throw custom validation, you can always use the following
throw ValidationException::withMessages(['name' => 'Something is wrong']);

Passing variable from middleware to controllers __construct to prevent repeating myself

I'm doing an existence check within a middleware, by checking a route-parameter.
If the check succeeds, I'm attaching it's model to the request to make it available throughout the rest of the request-cycle, application.
// App\Http\Middleware\CheckForExistence.php:
...
public function handle($request, Closure $next)
{
// some checks...
// success
$request->attributes->add([
'company' => $someModel
]);
}
I now have a controller which 'needs' this information in a couple of methods. So my thought was to add it to the construct of the controller and add it as a protected var in the whole controller:
// App\Http\Controllers\MyController.php
<?php
use Illuminate\Http\Request;
class MyController extends Controller
{
protected $company;
public function __construct(Request $request)
{
$this->company = $request->attributes->get('company');
}
public function index()
{
dd($this->company); // returns null
}
}
This controllers index() returns null instead of the give model.
If I change the index() method to:
public function index(Request $request)
{
return $request->attributes->get('company');
}
This returns the model; as expected.
Why is this happening? It looks like the middleware is not run when the controller is constructed.... Is there a way to circumvent it?
Or am I missing the obvious here.....
I could off course repeat myself in each method; but that is not very DRY ;)
You can't access the session or authenticated user in your controller's constructor because the middleware has not run yet, So you can do it like this :
public function __construct()
{
$this->middleware(function ($request, $next) {
$this->company = $request->attributes->get('company');
return $next($request);
});
}
For reasons currently unclear to me, the controller object is constructed before the request changes are reflected in the request object. In short the request is not considered properly constructed when a controller is constructed. This post seems to imply that.
There's two ways to work around this (if for a second we ignore what you're trying to do).
Use request dependency injection
public function index(Request $request)
{
$compary = $request->attributes->get('company');
}
This is not really WET because you're just swapping $this->company with $request->attributes->get('company') it's just a refactor. You should be injecting the request in the controller action anyway and if you don't want to do that you can use the request() helper.
Use a callback middleware in the constructor (Maraboc's answer explains how)
Now if you want a more case specific solution though you can use case specific dependency injection:
If you need to bind a model to a specific route parameter you can use route model binding and add the following in your RouteServiceProvider (or any provider).
Route::bind("companyAsARouteVarName", function () {
// this is why more details in the question are invaluable. I don't know if this is the right way for you.
//checks
// success
return $someModel;
});
Then you will register your route as:
Route::get("/something/{companyAsARouteVarName}", "SomeController#index");
and your controller will be:
public function index(Company $companyAsARouteVarName) {
//Magic
}
Controller constructor will be initialized before middleware execution.
You can get data from Injected $request object in controller functions.

Specify different set of rules based on which function makes the request

I wish to create a Request in a Laravel 5.1 application which has a specific set of rules based on the function that calls it.
For example, say, there are two functions in UsersController namely, login() and register(). The login() function requires only two inputs- username and password, whereas the register() function requires three inputs- username, password and email among other constraints. How can I create a single Request, call it UserRequest, that can handle the rules corresponding to both the above functions based on whichever makes the Request?
I am not sure if what I'm attempting could be done, or whether it is a good practice. Please suggest regarding the same as well.
You have a lot of flexibility since you can do whatever in rules() method, you just need a way to distinguish who is using the Request.
For this example, i would simply use the route() method(it tells you what route was called), you can do something like this:
class MyRequest extends Request {
/*
* Request rules
*/
protected $rules = [
// login rules
'login_route' => [
'login' => 'required',
],
// register rules
'register_route' => [
'login' => 'sometimes',
],
// depends if you need it
'default' => [
'login' => 'sometimes',
]
];
public function authorize()
{
return true; // or whatever
}
public function rules()
{
// where did this request come from?
$route = $this->route();
if(array_key_exists($route, $this->rules))
return $this->rules[$route];
return $this->rules['default'];
}
}
There are other ways, it depends on your problem, you could check the request method (GET, POST..) using getMethod() or check a segment, or instanciate an object on construct (dependency injection) to check if a user is logged in or not for example, really, it depends.
However, if the use case is complex, it is better to seperate in two requests.
Hope this helps.
You mean form requests. Before your method will be excecuted, the validator checks the rules. If not valid, the not-valid messages array will be returned with http status 422. See example below from https://mattstauffer.co/blog/laravel-5.0-form-requests
<?php namespace App\Http\Controllers;
use App\Http\Requests\FriendFormRequest;
use Illuminate\Routing\Controller;
use Response;
use View;
class FriendsController extends Controller
{
public function getAddFriend()
{
return view('friends.add');
}
public function postAddFriend(FriendFormRequest $request)
{
return Response::make('Friend added!');
}
}
And then your form request class:
<?php namespace App\Http\Requests;
use Illuminate\Foundation\Http\FormRequest;
use Response;
class FriendFormRequest extends FormRequest
{
public function rules()
{
return [
'first_name' => 'required',
'email_address' => 'required|email'
];
}
public function authorize()
{
// Only allow logged in users
// return \Auth::check();
// Allows all users in
return true;
}
// OPTIONAL OVERRIDE
public function forbiddenResponse()
{
// Optionally, send a custom response on authorize failure
// (default is to just redirect to initial page with errors)
//
// Can return a response, a view, a redirect, or whatever else
return Response::make('Permission denied foo!', 403);
}
// OPTIONAL OVERRIDE
public function response()
{
// If you want to customize what happens on a failed validation,
// override this method.
// See what it does natively here:
}
}
You can make different 'standalone' form requests and use them for your controller methods.
Official documentation here: http://laravel.com/docs/master/validation#form-request-validation

Categories