I have 2 servers available for failover. The database is replicated (MySQL) as a Master-Master, such that, each server runs a copy of the full-stack. I see the session table get updated when I'm on one server, and after inspecting the requests, I see the same PHPSESSID being sent. But, when I change URLs or failover to the secondary machine, my session is killed and I have to re-login.
Same PHPSESSID value is sent on the secondary, but the session is not recognized. Is Apache/PHP linking the session to that particular box? If so, how can I get them to recognize the session that is already in the database?
Note: Moved from 'EDIT' to an answer to mark as answered
Actually found the solution. The 'problem' is the Suhosin patch for securing the PHP installation. Suhosin supports configurable options for encrypting the session data based on a crypt key, as well as the DocRoot of the application, since the failover server had a different DocRoot, there was no chance of the encrypted data being read.
I edited suhosin.ini to add a shared crypt key, and turned off the DocRoot encryption option, and the sessions are shared as expected.
Solution via: http://rommelsantor.com/clog/2011/02/06/php-shared-session-encoding-solution/
If you're using $_SESSION then that is tied down to that server. You should use a cookie to track session ids and then match it back up with a session in the DB.
Related
Who creates a session and how does cookie and any role in it?
I was asked this question in a company's interview process and didn't know the answer. I would like to to know which side creates Sessions i.e whether the client side or server side and does cookie has any role in it.
Also how the server understands which session is provided to which client and which user of client if multiple users are logged in?
What’s the difference between a cookie and a session in PHP?
PHP sessions improve upon cookies because they allow web applications to store and retrieve more information than cookies. PHP sessions actually use cookies, but they add more functionality and security.
Sessions store data on the server, not on the browser like cookies
The main difference between a session and a cookie is that session data is stored on the server, whereas cookies store data in the visitor’s browser. Sessions use a session identifier to locate a particular user’s session data. This session identifier is normally stored in the user’s web browser in a cookie, but the sensitive data that needs to be more secure — like the user’s ID, name, etc. — will always stay on the server.
Sessions are more secure than cookies
So, why exactly should we use sessions when cookies work just fine? Well, as we already mentioned, sessions are more secure because the relevant information is stored on the server and not sent back and forth between the client and server. The second reason is that some users either turn off cookies or reject them. In that scenario, sessions, while designed to work with a cookie, can actually work without cookies as a workaround, as you can read about here: Can PHP sessions work without cookies?.
Sessions need extra space, unlike cookies
PHP sessions, unlike cookies which are just stored on the user’s browser, need a temporary directory on the server where PHP can store the session data. For servers running Unix this isn’t a problem at all, because the /tmp directory is meant to be used for things like this. But, if your server is running Windows and a version of PHP earlier than 4.3.6, then the server will need to be configured – here is what to do: Create a new folder on your Windows server – you can call it something like C:\temp. You want to be sure that every user can read and write to this folder. Then, you will need to edit your php.ini file, and set the value of session.save_path to point to the folder which you created on the Windows server (in this case, that folder is under C:\temp). And finally, you will need to restart your web server so that the changes in the php.ini file take effect.
Sessions must use the session_start function
A very important thing to remember when using sessions is that each page that will use a session must begin by calling the session_start() function. The session_start() function tells PHP to either start a brand new session or access an existing one.
How session_start in PHP uses cookies
The first time the session_start() function is used, it will try to send a cookie with a name of PHPSESSID and a value of something that looks like a30f8670baa8e10a44c878df89a2044b – which is the session identifier that contains 32 hexadecimal letters. Because cookies must be sent before any data is sent to the browser, this also means that session_start must be called before any data is sent to the Web browser.
link-1
link-2
link-3
link-4
The server creates the session and sets the cookie, which is stored in the client's browser. The cookie contains a session identifier (a string of characters) that allows the user to access a particular session on the server. This session identifier corresponds to the session on file.
Hi I have to retrieve data from several web servers. First I login as a user to my web site. After successfull login I have to fetch data from different web servers and display. How can I share a single session with multiple servers. How can I achieve this?
When I first login it create session and session id saved on temp folder of that server. When I try to access another server how can I use current session that already created when I logged in. Can anybody suggest a solution?
You'll have to use another session handler.
You can:
build your own (see session_set_save_handler) or
use extensions that provide their own session handler, like memcached
In complement to all these answers:
If you store sessions in databases, check that garbage collecting of sessions in PHP is really activated (it's not the case on Debian-like distributions, they decided to garbage sessions with their own cron and altered the php.ini so that it never launch any gc, so check the session.gc_probability and session.gc_divisor). The main problem of sessionstorage in database is that it means a lot of write queries and a lot of conflicting access in the database. This is a great way of stressing a database server like MySQL. So IMHO using another solution is better, this keeps your read/write ratio in a better web-database way.
You could also keep the file storage system and simply share the file directory between servers with NFS. Alter the session.save_path setting to use something other than /tmp. But NFS is by definition not the fastest wày of using a disk. Prefer memcached or mongodb for fast access.
If the only thing you need to share between the server is authentification, then instead of sharing the real session storage you could share authentification credentials. Like the OpenId system in SO, it's what we call an SSO, for the web part you have several solutions, from OpenId to CAS, and others. If the data is merged on the client side (ajax, ESI-gate) then you do not really need a common session data storage on server-side. This will avoid having 3 of your 5 impacted web application writing data in the shared session in the same time. Other session sharing techniques (database, NFS, even memcached) are mostly used to share your data between several servers because Load Balancing tools can put your sequential HTTP request from one server to another, but if you really mean parallel gathering of data you should really study SSO.
Another option would be to use memcached to store the sessions.
The important thing is that you must have a shared resource - be it a SQL database, memcached, a NoSQL database, etc. that all servers can access. You then use session_set_save_handler to access the shared resource.
Store sessions in a database which is accessible from the whole server pool.
Store it in a database - get all servers to connect to that same database. First result for "php store session in database"
is it possible and how to pass php session variables i have with a php and apache.
I have a main site with log in option for my users that runs from apache server and I want to use nginx as a chat/communication server that automatically gets all session variables i have in apache/php session without to pass php session id (for security reason). Both servers have a same ip and stais on a same domain. Nginx server will be on subdomain. Already have set php session to work on any sub domain but is this is valid also if I use nginx server.
Any example will be helpful.
Thanks in advanced.
Technically, the php sessions are files, which are usually located somewhere in /tmp. So once you've the session cookie, you can just read and unserialize the file's contents — after checking, it goes without saying, that the session is not expired.
If you need a more convenient format, look at php's session options. I'm quite sure you can serialize it as json for more portability, and there are ways to store sessions in SQL or even memcached.
Session ID is stored on the client in a way that usually dissipates when the browser is closed (stored as a cookie?).
Session ID and associated data is stored on the server (where?) for each client that starts one.
The main thing I wonder about is how the server knows when a session has ended, though. If the client no longer has the session ID stored (say, after closing their browser) and they try to ask the server for another session, it starts a new session. Does the server know to garbage collect the previous session data after some set amount of time? It seems to me like something that could be abused...
Session ID is usually stored on client browser using a cookie (alternatively, in URL parameters, but this is not recommended, as explained in http://php.net/manual/en/session.security.php)
Sessions are stored in the directory defined by session.save_path (e.g. /var/lib/php/sessions), or the system's temporary directory if this is not set (usually /tmp).
Sessions are garbage collected periodically, either by PHP itself during a request, or by a cron job (e.g. on Debian this is the default). See http://php.net/manual/en/session.configuration.php#ini.session.gc-probability
The main thing I wonder about is how the server knows when a session has ended
He doesn't know. However he knows when a session has not been used since a certain period of time, so it can delete unused sessions.
Does the server know to garbage collect the previous session data after some set amount of time?
Yes. This is defined by the session.gc_maxlifetime ini setting. Any session older than that will be deleted during a garbage collect. Garbage collect frequency can be tuned with the session.gc_probability and session.gc_divisor ini settings. (See doc.)
It seems to me like something that could be abused.
If you mean that someone may be able to create too many staled sessions on the server; yes this is probably true.
what you describe is perfectly right. And yes, it can be abused easily. There's even a tool out that automatically hijacks sessions around you (search for firesheep). The sessions are usually stored as either SESSION cookies or are passed between sever and client each time.
Check the PHP for a very brief intro, and some google on session and security will get you further.
Sessions expire automatically and are cleared up depending on the settings (after 20 days of no usage for example) and they are stored on linux, usually under /tmp/
Check php.ini for more information
I had some thoughts back ago about using memcached for session storage, but came to the conclusion that it wouldn't be sufficient in the event of one or more of the servers in the memcached pool were about to go down.
A hybrid version is to save the main database (mySQL) from load caused by reads would be to work out a function that tries to fetch the data from the cache pool, and if that fails gets it from the database.
After putting some more thought into it, I started to think about using APC cache for session related data. If our web server would go down, sessions would be lost either way, so storing them in a local APC or a localhost memcached server maybe isn't that bad?
What's your experiences?
Generally, session data is something which should be treated as volatile in any situation. The user can always choose to eliminate the cookie themselves at any point (if you are using cookies, of course). For this reason, I see no problem with using memcached for session data.
For me, I'd just keep it simple - no need for a DB fallback unless you absolutely must never lose the user's session in the event of a memcached server failure. As I said at the beginning, I always treat sessions as purely volatile in any case and don't really store anything of any significance in them.
That's my two cents anyways.