Private static method vs. static method - php

Question

I understand that static means that an object doesn't need to be instantiated for that property/method to be available. I also understand how this applies to private properties and methods and public methods. What I'm trying to understand is what static private function gains you. For example:
class Beer {
static private $beertype = "IPA";
private function getBeerType() {
return self::$beertype;
}
static public function BeerInfo() {
return self::getBeerType();
}
}
print Beer::BeerInfo() . "\n";
The private method getBeerType() executes just fine without an instantiated object as long as it's being called from a static public method. If a static public method has access to all private methods (static and non-static), what's the benefit of declaring a method static private?
With strict error reporting turned on, I do get the warning that I should make getBeerType() static, although it still lets me run the code. And I did a little research and it seems like other languages (Java) will force you to declare a private method as static when called by a static public method. Looks like PHP lets you get away with this. Is there a way to force it to throw an error and not execute?

Answer 1

A static private method provides a way to hide static code from outside the class. This can be useful if several different methods (static or not) need to use it, i.e. code-reuse.
Static methods and static variables, sometimes called class methods and class variables, are a way of putting code and data into a kind of namespace. You could also think of class variables as variables attached to the class itself, of which there is (by definition) exactly one, instead of to instances of that class, of which there may be zero, one or many. Class methods and class variables can be useful in working with attributes that not just remain same in all instances, but actually be the same.
An example of a class variable is a database handler in an ORM entity object. All instances are their own object, but they all need access to the same database handler for loading and saving themselves.
Private versus public is a completely separate quality, which is I suspect what you're stumbling over. A private method cannot be called and private variables cannot be accessed from code outside the class. Private methods are usually used to implement "internal" logic on the object that must not be accessible from outside the object. This restriction can be needed by instance methods as well as class methods.
An example of a private class method could be in a factory method. There might be three factory calls for creating an object which might differ in parameters being supplied. Yet the bulk of the operation is the same. So it goes into a private static method that the non-private factory methods call.

Answer 2

I understand static means that an object doesn't need to be instantiated for that property/method to be available.
Everything static just exists. Globally.
I also understand how this applies to public properties and methods and public methods
Are you sure you have understood that it creates a global variable and a standard global function?
What I'm trying to understand is what static private function gains you.
The private is just a specifier of visibilityDocs. So that gains you visibility control.
Is it useful? Depends on the use-case.

Answer 3

it's for preventing OTHERS from consuming it.
Example, you have a Logger static object, then you have two public static methods LogOk and LogError and both benefeit from an "internal" method Log but you don't want the consumers of that class to be able to call Log directly.
You can call Logger::LogOk( "All right." ); but you cannot call Logger::Log( "abc" ); if Log is private.
You you can internally always make use of it from the same class.

Answer 4

Although the code works, it throws a Strict standards error:
Strict standards: Non-static method Beer::getBeerType() should not be
called statically
So, here you get the use of the private static.

Answer 5

Simply said you can declare a private static function if you have a repeated operation in some of the public static functions in the class.
Naturally if you are an inexperienced programmer or new to the OOP putting limitations to your code seem strange. But strict declarations like this will make your code cleaner and easier to maintain.
In large projects and complex classes you can appreciate to know exactly what to expect from a function and exactly how you can use it.
Here is a good read: Single responsibility principle and
God Object

Answer 6

Here's the rule and the best answer,
static methods cannot access non-static variables and methods, since these require an instance of the class. Don't worry about the warning, the rule is set and it will break your code in the future once it's fully enforced. That is why
static public function BeerInfo() {
return self::getBeerType()
is wrong,
you have to declare getBeerType as static.

Answer 7

In your example, you can simplify this by doing the following.
static private $beertype = "IPA";
static public function BeerInfo() {
return self::$beertype;
}
'static' purely means resident in a single region of memory. If you are memory conscious, static implementations are a good strategy.
When you use a public static function, chances are, most of the time, that you don't want to deal with an instance of that class, but want to re-use pre-existing functionality from within that class. Leveraging private static functions is the way to do that without instances.
However, you could have a public static function which accepts an argument which is an instance of said class, e.g.
static public function doSomething(Beer &$ref) {
$ref->instanceLevelFunction(...);
}