Testing if a network in cidr notation overlaps another network - php

Question

I'm searching for a php algorithm that efficiently test if one cidr notated network overlaps another.
Basically I have the following situation:
Array of cidr adresses:
$cidrNetworks = array(
'192.168.10.0/24',
'10.10.0.30/20',
etc.
);
I have a method that adds networks to the array, but this method should throw an exception when a network is added that overlaps with a network allready in the array.
So ie. if 192.168.10.0/25 is added an exception should be thrown.
Does anyone have/know/"can think of" an method to test this efficiently?

Answer 1

Here is an updated version of the class previously discussed in chat. It can do what you require, as well as many other useful things.
<?php
class IPv4Subnet implements ArrayAccess, Iterator {
/*
* Address format constants
*/
const ADDRESS_BINARY = 0x01;
const ADDRESS_INT = 0x02;
const ADDRESS_DOTDEC = 0x04;
const ADDRESS_SUBNET = 0x08;
/*
* Constants to control whether getHosts() returns the network/broadcast addresses
*/
const HOSTS_WITH_NETWORK = 0x10;
const HOSTS_WITH_BROADCAST = 0x20;
const HOSTS_ALL = 0x30;
/*
* Properties to store base address and subnet mask as binary strings
*/
protected $address;
protected $mask;
/*
* Counter to track the current iteration offset
*/
private $iteratorOffset = 0;
/*
* Array to hold values retrieved via ArrayAccess
*/
private $arrayAccessObjects = array();
/*
* Helper methods
*/
private function longToBinary ($long) {
return pack('N', $long);
}
private function longToDottedDecimal ($long) {
return ($long >> 24 & 0xFF).'.'.($long >> 16 & 0xFF).'.'.($long >> 8 & 0xFF).'.'.($long & 0xFF);
}
private function longToByteArray ($long) {
return array(
$long >> 24 & 0xFF,
$long >> 16 & 0xFF,
$long >> 8 & 0xFF,
$long & 0xFF
);
}
private function longToSubnet ($long) {
if (!isset($this->arrayAccessObjects[$long])) {
$this->arrayAccessObjects[$long] = new self($long);
}
return $this->arrayAccessObjects[$long];
}
private function binaryToLong ($binary) {
return current(unpack('N', $binary));
}
private function binaryToDottedDecimal ($binary) {
return implode('.', unpack('C*', $binary));
}
private function binaryToX ($binary, $mode) {
if ($mode & self::ADDRESS_BINARY) {
$result = $binary;
} else if ($mode & self::ADDRESS_INT) {
$result = $this->binaryToLong($binary);
} else if ($mode & self::ADDRESS_DOTDEC) {
$result = $this->binaryToDottedDecimal($binary);
} else {
$result = $this->longToSubnet($this->binaryToLong($binary));
}
return $result;
}
private function byteArrayToLong($bytes) {
return ($bytes[0] << 24) | ($bytes[1] << 16) | ($bytes[2] << 8) | $bytes[3];
}
private function byteArrayToBinary($bytes) {
return pack('C*', $bytes[0], $bytes[1], $bytes[2], $bytes[3]);
}
private function normaliseComparisonSubject (&$subject) {
if (!is_object($subject)) {
$subject = new self($subject);
}
if (!($subject instanceof self)) {
throw new InvalidArgumentException('Subject must be an instance of IPv4Subnet');
}
}
private function validateOctetArray (&$octets) {
foreach ($octets as &$octet) {
$octet = (int) $octet;
if ($octet < 0 || $octet > 255) {
return FALSE;
}
}
return TRUE;
}
/*
* Constructor
*/
public function __construct ($address = NULL, $mask = NULL) {
if ($address === NULL || (is_string($address) && trim($address) === '')) {
$address = array(0, 0, 0, 0);
} else if (is_int($address)) {
$address = $this->longToByteArray($address);
} else if (is_string($address)) {
$parts = preg_split('#\s*/\s*#', trim($address), -1, PREG_SPLIT_NO_EMPTY);
if (count($parts) > 2) {
throw new InvalidArgumentException('No usable IP address supplied: Syntax error');
} else if ($parts[0] === '') {
throw new InvalidArgumentException('No usable IP address supplied: IP address empty');
}
if (!empty($parts[1]) && !isset($mask)) {
$mask = $parts[1];
}
$address = preg_split('#\s*\.\s*#', $parts[0], -1, PREG_SPLIT_NO_EMPTY);
} else if (is_array($address)) {
$address = array_values($address);
} else {
throw new InvalidArgumentException('No usable IP address supplied: Value must be a string or an integer');
}
$suppliedAddressOctets = count($address);
$address += array(0, 0, 0, 0);
if ($suppliedAddressOctets > 4) {
throw new InvalidArgumentException('No usable IP address supplied: IP address has more than 4 octets');
} else if (!$this->validateOctetArray($address)) {
throw new InvalidArgumentException('No usable IP address supplied: At least one octet value outside acceptable range 0 - 255');
}
if ($mask === NULL) {
$mask = array_pad(array(), $suppliedAddressOctets, 255) + array(0, 0, 0, 0);
} else if (is_int($mask)) {
$mask = $this->longToByteArray($mask);
} else if (is_string($mask)) {
$mask = preg_split('#\s*\.\s*#', trim($mask), -1, PREG_SPLIT_NO_EMPTY);
switch (count($mask)) {
case 1: // CIDR
$cidr = (int) $mask[0];
if ($cidr === 0) {
// Shifting 32 bits on a 32 bit system doesn't work, so treat this as a special case
$mask = array(0, 0, 0, 0);
} else if ($cidr <= 32) {
// This looks odd, but it's the nicest way I have found to get the 32 least significant bits set in a
// way that works on both 32 and 64 bit platforms
$base = ~((~0 << 16) << 16);
$mask = $this->longToByteArray($base << (32 - $cidr));
} else {
throw new InvalidArgumentException('Supplied mask invalid: CIDR outside acceptable range 0 - 32');
}
break;
case 4: break; // Dotted decimal
default: throw new InvalidArgumentException('Supplied mask invalid: Must be either a full dotted-decimal or a CIDR');
}
} else if (is_array($mask)) {
$mask = array_values($mask);
} else {
throw new InvalidArgumentException('Supplied mask invalid: Type invalid');
}
if (!$this->validateOctetArray($mask)) {
throw new InvalidArgumentException('Supplied mask invalid: At least one octet value outside acceptable range 0 - 255');
}
// Check bits are contiguous from left
// TODO: Improve this mechanism
$asciiBits = sprintf('%032b', $this->byteArrayToLong($mask));
if (strpos(rtrim($asciiBits, '0'), '0') !== FALSE) {
throw new InvalidArgumentException('Supplied mask invalid: Set bits are not contiguous from the most significant bit');
}
$this->mask = $this->byteArrayToBinary($mask);
$this->address = $this->byteArrayToBinary($address) & $this->mask;
}
/*
* ArrayAccess interface methods (read only)
*/
public function offsetExists ($offset) {
if ($offset === 'network' || $offset === 'broadcast') {
return TRUE;
}
$offset = filter_var($offset, FILTER_VALIDATE_INT);
if ($offset === FALSE || $offset < 0) {
return FALSE;
}
return $offset < $this->getHostsCount();
}
public function offsetGet ($offset) {
if (!$this->offsetExists($offset)) {
return NULL;
}
if ($offset === 'network') {
$address = $this->getNetworkAddress(self::ADDRESS_INT);
} else if ($offset === 'broadcast') {
$address = $this->getBroadcastAddress(self::ADDRESS_INT);
} else {
// How much the address needs to be adjusted by to account for network address
$adjustment = (int) ($this->getHostsCount() > 2);
$address = $this->binaryToLong($this->address) + $offset + $adjustment;
}
return $this->longToSubnet($address);
}
public function offsetSet ($offset, $value) {}
public function offsetUnset ($offset) {}
/*
* Iterator interface methods
*/
public function current () {
return $this->offsetGet($this->iteratorOffset);
}
public function key () {
return $this->iteratorOffset;
}
public function next () {
$this->iteratorOffset++;
}
public function rewind () {
$this->iteratorOffset = 0;
}
public function valid () {
return $this->iteratorOffset < $this->getHostsCount();
}
/*
* Data access methods
*/
public function getHosts ($mode = self::ADDRESS_SUBNET) {
// Parse flags and initialise vars
$bin = (bool) ($mode & self::ADDRESS_BINARY);
$int = (bool) ($mode & self::ADDRESS_INT);
$dd = (bool) ($mode & self::ADDRESS_DOTDEC);
$base = $this->binaryToLong($this->address);
$mask = $this->binaryToLong($this->mask);
$hasNwBc = !($mask & 0x03);
$result = array();
// Get network address if requested
if (($mode & self::HOSTS_WITH_NETWORK) && $hasNwBc) {
$result[] = $base;
}
// Get hosts
for ($current = $hasNwBc ? $base + 1 : $base; ($current & $mask) === $base; $current++) {
$result[] = $current;
}
// Remove broadcast address if present and not requested
if ($hasNwBc && !($mode & self::HOSTS_WITH_BROADCAST)) {
array_pop($result);
}
// Convert to the correct type
if ($bin) {
$result = array_map(array($this, 'longToBinary'), $result);
} else if ($dd) {
$result = array_map(array($this, 'longToDottedDecimal'), $result);
} else if (!$int) {
$result = array_map(array($this, 'longToSubnet'), $result);
}
return $result;
}
public function getHostsCount () {
$count = $this->getBroadcastAddress(self::ADDRESS_INT) - $this->getNetworkAddress(self::ADDRESS_INT);
return $count > 2 ? $count - 1 : $count + 1; // Adjust return value to exclude network/broadcast addresses
}
public function getNetworkAddress ($mode = self::ADDRESS_SUBNET) {
return $this->binaryToX($this->address, $mode);
}
public function getBroadcastAddress ($mode = self::ADDRESS_SUBNET) {
return $this->binaryToX($this->address | ~$this->mask, $mode);
}
public function getMask ($mode = self::ADDRESS_DOTDEC) {
return $this->binaryToX($this->mask, $mode);
}
/*
* Stringify methods
*/
public function __toString () {
if ($this->getHostsCount() === 1) {
$result = $this->toDottedDecimal();
} else {
$result = $this->toCIDR();
}
return $result;
}
public function toDottedDecimal () {
$result = $this->getNetworkAddress(self::ADDRESS_DOTDEC);
if ($this->mask !== "\xFF\xFF\xFF\xFF") {
$result .= '/'.$this->getMask(self::ADDRESS_DOTDEC);
}
return $result;
}
public function toCIDR () {
$address = $this->getNetworkAddress(self::ADDRESS_DOTDEC);
$cidr = strlen(trim(sprintf('%b', $this->getMask(self::ADDRESS_INT)), '0')); // TODO: Improve this mechanism
return $address.'/'.$cidr;
}
/*
* Comparison methods
*/
public function contains ($subject) {
$this->normaliseComparisonSubject($subject);
$subjectAddress = $subject->getNetworkAddress(self::ADDRESS_BINARY);
$subjectMask = $subject->getMask(self::ADDRESS_BINARY);
return $this->mask !== $subjectMask && ($this->mask | ($this->mask ^ $subjectMask)) !== $this->mask && ($subjectAddress & $this->mask) === $this->address;
}
public function within ($subject) {
$this->normaliseComparisonSubject($subject);
$subjectAddress = $subject->getNetworkAddress(self::ADDRESS_BINARY);
$subjectMask = $subject->getMask(self::ADDRESS_BINARY);
return $this->mask !== $subjectMask && ($this->mask | ($this->mask ^ $subjectMask)) === $this->mask && ($this->address & $subjectMask) === $subjectAddress;
}
public function equalTo ($subject) {
$this->normaliseComparisonSubject($subject);
return $this->address === $subject->getNetworkAddress(self::ADDRESS_BINARY) && $this->mask === $subject->getMask(self::ADDRESS_BINARY);
}
public function intersect ($subject) {
$this->normaliseComparisonSubject($subject);
return $this->equalTo($subject) || $this->contains($subject) || $this->within($subject);
}
}
In order to do what you desire, the class provides 4 methods:
contains()
within()
equalTo()
intersect()
Example usage of these:
// Also accepts dotted decimal mask. The mask may also be passed to the second
// argument. Any valid combination of dotted decimal, CIDR and integers will be
// accepted
$subnet = new IPv4Subnet('192.168.0.0/24');
// These methods will accept a string or another instance
var_dump($subnet->contains('192.168.0.1')); //TRUE
var_dump($subnet->contains('192.168.1.1')); //FALSE
var_dump($subnet->contains('192.168.0.0/16')); //FALSE
var_dump($subnet->within('192.168.0.0/16')); //TRUE
// ...hopefully you get the picture. intersect() returns TRUE if any of the
// other three match.
The class also implements the Iterator interface, allowing you to iterate over all the addresses in a subnet. The iterator excludes the network and broadcast addresses, which can be retrieved separately.
Example:
$subnet = new IPv4Subnet('192.168.0.0/28');
echo "Network: ", $subnet->getNetworkAddress(),
"; Broadcast: ", $subnet->getBroadcastAddress(),
"\nHosts:\n";
foreach ($subnet as $host) {
echo $host, "\n";
}
The class also implements ArrayAccess, allowing you to treat it as an array:
$subnet = new IPv4Subnet('192.168.0.0/28');
echo $subnet['network'], "\n"; // 192.168.0.0
echo $subnet[0], "\n"; // 192.168.0.1
// ...
echo $subnet[13], "\n"; // 192.168.0.14
echo $subnet['broadcast'], "\n"; // 192.168.0.15
NB: The iterator/array methods of accessing the subnet's host addresses will return another IPv4Subnet object. The class implements __toString(), which will return the IP address as a dotted decimal if it represents a single address, or the CIDR if it represents more than one. The data can be accessed directly as a string or an integer by calling the relevant get*() method and passing the desired flag(s) (see constants defined at the top of the class).
All operations are 32- and 64-bit safe. Compatibility should be (although not thoroughly tested) 5.2+
See it working
For completeness, I imagine your use case would be implemented something along these lines:
public function addSubnet ($newSubnet) {
$newSubnet = new IPv4Subnet($newSubnet);
foreach ($this->subnets as &$existingSubnet) {
if ($existingSubnet->contains($newSubnet)) {
throw new Exception('Subnet already added');
} else if ($existingSubnet->within($newSubnet)) {
$existingSubnet = $newSubnet;
return;
}
}
$this->subnets[] = $newSubnet;
}
See it working

Answer 2

As discussed briefly in PHP chat, here's how I would implement it, to compare any two addresses.
Convert the IP addresses to their binary form
Extract the masks from the CIDR format
Take the minimum mask of the two (least specific =
contains more addresses)
Use the mask on both binary representations.
Compare the two.
If there is a match, then one is contained within the other.
Here's some example code, it's not very pretty and you'll want to adapt it to cater for your array.
function bin_pad($num)
{
return str_pad(decbin($num), 8, '0', STR_PAD_LEFT);
}
$ip1 = '192.168.0.0/23';
$ip2 = '192.168.1.0/24';
$regex = '~(\d+)\.(\d+)\.(\d+)\.(\d+)/(\d+)~';
preg_match($regex, $ip1, $ip1);
preg_match($regex, $ip2, $ip2);
$mask = min($ip1[5], $ip2[5]);
$ip1 = substr(
bin_pad($ip1[1]) . bin_pad($ip1[2]) .
bin_pad($ip1[3]) . bin_pad($ip1[4]),
0, $mask
);
$ip2 = substr(
bin_pad($ip2[1]) . bin_pad($ip2[2]) .
bin_pad($ip2[3]) . bin_pad($ip2[4]),
0, $mask
);
var_dump($ip1, $ip2, $ip1 === $ip2);
I had trouble making it 32 bit compatible, which is why I eventually opted for converting each octet of the IP address into binary individually, and then using substr.
I started off using pack('C4', $ip[1] .. $ip[4]) but when it came to using a full 32 bit mask I ran into problems converting it into binary (since PHP integers are signed). Thought for a future implementation though!

Answer 3

Intuitively I would suggest you'd want to do something like:
Let the new entry be X
Convert X to single integer form, let that integer be Y
Let mask length of any entry A be mask(A)
Compare any existing entries where mask(entry) = mask(Y)
Mask off existing entries where mask(entry) > mask(Y) and compare with Y
Mask off Y for each existing entry where mask(entry) < mask(X), such that mask(Y) = mask(entry) and compare
Provided you encounter no collisions, all is well.
Of course this does not check if the proposed subnet is valid.
My proposition of correctness here is that I can't think of a counter-example, but there may well be one so I offer this as a basis for further thought - hope this helps.

Answer 4

<?php
function checkOverlap ($net1, $net2) {
$mask1 = explode("/", $net1)[1];
$net1 = explode("/", $net1)[0];
$netArr1 = explode(".",$net1);
$mask2 = explode("/", $net2)[1];
$net2 = explode("/", $net2)[0];
$netArr2 = explode(".",$net2);
$newnet1 = $newnet2 = "";
foreach($netArr1 as $num) {
$binnum = decbin($num);
$length = strlen($binnum);
for ($i = 0; $i < 8-$length; $i++) {
$binnum = '0'.$binnum;
}
$newnet1 .= $binnum;
}
foreach($netArr2 as $num) {
$binnum = decbin($num);
$length = strlen($binnum);
for ($i = 0; $i < 8-$length; $i++) {
$binnum = '0'.$binnum;
}
$newnet2 .= $binnum;
}
$length = min($mask1, $mask2);
$newnet1 = substr($newnet1,0,$length);
$newnet2 = substr($newnet2,0,$length);
$overlap = 0;
if ($newnet1 == $newnet2) $overlap = 1;
return $overlap;
}
function networksOverlap ($networks, $newnet) {
$overlap = false;
foreach ($networks as $network) {
$overlap = checkOverlap($network, $newnet);
if ($overlap) return 1;
}
return $overlap;
}
$cidrNetworks = array(
'192.168.10.0/24',
'10.10.0.30/20'
);
$newnet = "192.168.10.0/25";
$overlap = networksOverlap($cidrNetworks, $newnet);
?>
Not sure if this is 100% correct but try it out see if it works.