Getting column value when SQL query has aliases - php

Question

I have a SQL query that has alias in it. The problem is, when I try to get the values of columns it doesn't show the correct values:
$sql = "SELECT p.ID, p.ProfileID, p.ModuleID, p.View, p.Add, p.Edit, p.Delete, m.Name, m.ID FROM permission AS p, module AS m WHERE p.ModuleID = m.ID ORDER BY p.ProfileID ASC, m.Name ASC";
$result = array();
$i = 0;
foreach ($this->dbconnect->query($sql) as $row)
{
$result[$i] = array(
'ID' => $row['p.ID'],
'ProfileID' => $row['p.ProfileID'],
'ModuleID' => $row['p.ModuleID'],
'View' => $row['p.View'],
'Add' => $row['p.Add'],
'Edit' => $row['p.Edit'],
'Delete' => $row['p.Delete']);
$i += 1;
}
Running shows no value when in the database it's actually 10.
If I change the above code to the following:
$sql = "SELECT p.ID, p.ProfileID, p.ModuleID, p.View, p.Add, p.Edit, p.Delete, m.Name, m.ID FROM permission AS p, module AS m WHERE p.ModuleID = m.ID ORDER BY p.ProfileID ASC, m.Name ASC";
$result = array();
$i = 0;
foreach ($this->dbconnect->query($sql) as $row)
{
$result[$i] = array(
'ID' => $row['ID'],
'ProfileID' => $row['ProfileID'],
'ModuleID' => $row['ModuleID'],
'View' => $row['View'],
'Add' => $row['Add'],
'Edit' => $row['Edit'],
'Delete' => $row['Delete']);
$i += 1;
}
Miraculously, running shows the value of m.ID instead of p.ID. It is strange why the first example is incorrect. Am I missing something here?

Answer 1

You should something like this...
SELECT p.ID as p_ID, ...
And
'ID' => $row['p_ID'],

Answer 2

Use aliases in SELECT to each column, which are same:
$sql = "SELECT p.ID AS permission_id, p.ProfileID, p.ModuleID, p.View, p.Add, p.Edit, p.Delete, m.Name, m.ID AS module_id FROM permission AS p, module AS m WHERE p.ModuleID = m.ID ORDER BY p.ProfileID ASC, m.Name ASC";
then:
foreach(...)
{
$result[$i] = array(
'Perm_ID' => $row['permission_id'],
'Module_ID' => $row['module_id'],
...
}