Separate two validations with same redirect - php

Question

I'm new in Laravel4 world, and I'm trying to convert my site to laravel framework. But at beginning I have a little problem. On index I have two jquery modal: first for singin and second for registration. So, I want to when user try to login and make a mistake to show him an error. Same for registration. But when I have error in singin form, I get register form...My english is bad, so here is code:
routes.php
Route::get('/', function()
{
return View::make("index.index");
}
Route::post('/', array('as'=> 'singin', function()
{
$data = Input::all();
$rules = array(
'username' => 'min:3',
'password' => 'min:6'
);
$validation = Validator::make($data, $rules);
if($validation->passes())
{
return View::make('users.main');
}
Input::flash();
return Redirect::to('/')->withErrors($validation);
}));
Route::post('/', array('as'=> 'register', function()
{
// same as previous function
]
index.blade.php
<div id="signin" class="reveal-modal" #if($errors->all())
style="display:block; visibility:visible;" #endif >
<header class="reveal-modal-header">
Sign in
</header>
<div class="cont">
<div class="indication">
Sign In
</div>
{{ Form::open(array(
'route' => 'singin',
'class' => 'signin')) }}
<p class="clearfix">
{{ Form::label('username', 'Username') }}
{{ Form::text('username')}}
</p>
<p class="clearfix">
{{ Form::label('password', 'Password') }}
{{ Form::password('password')}}
</p>
<p class="without-label clearfix">
{{ Form::submit('') }}
</p>
#if($errors->all())
<div id="logindiverror" style="" class="alert alert-error">
#foreach($errors->all('<li>:message</li>') as $message)
{{ $message }}
#endforeach
</div>
#endif
{{ Form::close() }}
</div>
<a class="close-reveal-modal" id="close1" href="#">×</a>
</div>
<div id="signup" class="reveal-modal" #if($errors->all())
style="display:block; visibility:visible;" #endif >>
<header class="reveal-modal-header">
Sign up
</header>
<div class="cont">
<div class="indication">
Register
</div>
{{ Form::open(array(
'route' => 'register',
'class' => 'signup')) }}
<p class="clearfix">
<em>(<abbr>*</abbr>) All fields are required</em>
</p>
<p class="clearfix">
<label>Username:<abbr>*</abbr></label>
{{ Form::text('username')}}
</p>
<p class="clearfix">
<label>Email:<abbr>*</abbr></label>
{{ Form::text('email') }}
</p>
<p class="clearfix">
<label>Password:<abbr>*</abbr></label>
{{ Form::password('password1'); }}
</p>
<p class="clearfix">
<label>Password (repeat):<abbr>*</abbr></label>
{{ Form::password('password2'); }}
</p>
<p class="checkboxes clearfix">
<span class="niceCheck">{{ Form::checkbox('agree', '0') }}</span>
I agree with LinkyPlanet Terms & Privacy Policy
</p>
<p class="without-label clearfix">
{{ Form::submit('') }}
</p>
#if($errors->all())
<div id="logindiverror" style="" class="alert alert-error">
#foreach($errors->all('<li>:message</li>') as $message)
{{ $message }}
#endforeach
</div>
#endif
{{ Form::close() }}
</div>
<a class="close-reveal-modal" id="close2" href="#">×</a>
</div>
So, problem is when user try to sing in, and he make a mistake in password (pass is shorter than 6 chars), script redirect him to index and open modal for registration and there show an error, not in sing in modal. Where is mistake?
Cheers :)

Answer 1

The problem is that you have 2 "different" routes using the same URI (/) and the same method (POST), but you cannot.
Only the first one will work, by precedence. Something like this could be better:
Route::post('/singin', array('as'=> 'singin', function()
{
}));
Route::post('/register', array('as'=> 'register', function()
{
}));
Or you can keep one of them on / and change the other one:
Route::post('/', array('as'=> 'singin', function()
{
}));
Route::post('/register', array('as'=> 'register', function()
{
}));
EDIT:
You are using the same name for everything ($errors in register and sign in). If you have ONE view for both, you need to have different names. You can use
return Redirect::to('/')->with('registerErrors', $validation->messages());
and
return Redirect::to('/')->with('signInErrors', $validation->messages());
But on tedirects they are bound to your session, so you'll have to get them this way:
#if(Session::has('registerErrors'))
<div id="logindiverror" style="" class="alert alert-error">
#foreach(Session::get('registerErrors')->all('<li>:message</li>') as $message)
{{ $message }}
#endforeach
</div>
#endif