Record deleted during a transaction - php

Question

I have a system that handles many queries per second. I code my system with mysql and PHP.
My problem is mysqli transaction still commit the transaction even the record is deleted by other user at the same time , all my table are using InnoDB.
This is how I code my transaction with mysqli:
mysqli_autocommit($dbc,FALSE);
$all_query_ok=true;
$q="INSERT INTO Transaction() VALUES()";
mysqli_query ($dbc,$q)?null:$all_query_ok=false;
$q="INSERT INTO Statement() VALUES()";
mysqli_query ($dbc,$q)?null:$all_query_ok=false;
if($all_query_ok==true){
//all success
mysqli_commit($dbc);
}else{
//one of it failed , rollback everything.
mysqli_rollback($dbc);
}
Below are the query performed at the same time in other script by another user and then end up messing the expected system behaviour,
$q="DELETE FROM Transaction...";
mysqli_query ($dbc,$q)?null:$all_query_ok=false;
Please advice , did I implement the transaction wrongly? I have read about row-level locking and believe that innoDB does lock the record during a transaction

Answer 1

I don't know which kind of transactions you're talking about but with the mysqli extension I use the following methods to work with transactions:
mysqli::begin_transaction
mysqli::commit
mysqli::rollback
Then the process is like:
Starting a new transaction with mysqli::begin_transaction
Execute your SQL queries
On success use mysqli::commit to confirm changes done by your queries in step 2 OR on error during execution of your queries in step 2 use mysqli::rollback to revert changes done by them.
You can think of transactions like a temporary cache for your queries. It's someway similar to output caching in PHP with ob_* functions. As long as you didn't have flushed the cached data, nothing happens on screen. Same with transactions: as long as you didn't have commited anything (and autocommit is turned off) nothing happens in the database.

Answer 2

I did some research on row level locking which can lock record from delete or update
FOR UPDATE
Official Documentation
Right after the begin transaction I have to select those record I wanted to lock like below
SELECT * FROM Transaction WHERE id=1 FOR UPDATE
So that the record will be lock until transaction end.
This method doesn't work on MyISAM type table

Answer 3

Looks like a typical example of race condition. You execute two concurrent scripts modifying data in parallel. Probably your first script successfully inserts records and commits the transaction, and the second script successfully deletes records afterwards. I'm not sure what you mean by "the query performed at the same time in other script by other user" though.

Answer 4

You will have to do this this way:
mysqli_autocommit($dbc,FALSE);
$dbc->begin_transaction();
$all_query_ok=true;
$q="INSERT INTO Transaction() VALUES()";
mysqli_query ($dbc,$q)?null:$all_query_ok=false;
$q="INSERT INTO Statement() VALUES()";
mysqli_query ($dbc,$q)?null:$all_query_ok=false;
if($all_query_ok==true){
//all success
mysqli_commit($dbc);
}else{
//one of it failed , rollback everything.
mysqli_rollback($dbc);
}
you can use the object oriented or the procedural style when calling begin_transaction (I prefer the object oriented).