Is this dynamic SQL query generation safe from injections? - php

Question

Is there something that may escape the sanitation in my script or is it safe from most SQL injections? The way I understand it, if you pass query as prepared argument, it does not matter how the query was build, right?
Edit2: I edited the code to reflect the suggestions of binding the $_POST values
$q = $pdo->prepare('SHOW COLUMNS FROM my_table');
$q->execute();
$data = $q->fetchAll(PDO::FETCH_ASSOC);
$key = array();
foreach ($data as $word){
array_push($key,$word['Field']);
}
$sqlSub= "INSERT INTO other_table(";
$n = 0;
foreach ($key as $index){
$sqlSub = $sqlSub.$index.", ";
$n = $n + 1;
}
$sqlSub = $sqlSub.") VALUES (";
for ($i=1; $i<$n;$i++){
$sqlSub = $sqlSub."?, ";
}
$sqlSub = $sqlSub.."?)";
$keyValues = array();
for($i=0;i<n;$i++){
array_push($keyValues,$_POST[$key[$i]]);
}
$q->$pdo->prepare($sqlSub);
q->execute($keyValues);
EDIT: This is how the final query looks like after suggested edits
INSERT INTO other_table($key[0],...,$key[n]) VALUES (?,...,nth-?);

Answer 1

No. The example code shown is not safe from most SQL Injections.
You understanding is entirely wrong.
What matters is the SQL text. If that's being dynamically generated using potentially unsafe values, then the SQL text is vulnerable.
The code is vulnerable in multiple places. Even the names of the columns are potentially unsafe.
CREATE TABLE foo
( `Robert'; DROP TABLE Students; --` VARCHAR(2)
, `O``Reilly` VARCHAR(2)
);
SHOW COLUMNS FROM foo
FIELD TYPE NULL
-------------------------------- ---------- ----
Robert'; DROP TABLE Students; -- varchar(2) YES
O`Reilly varchar(2) YES
You would need to enclose the column identifiers in backticks, after escaping any backtick within the column identifier with another backtick.

Answer 2

As others have noted, make sure your column names are safe.
SQL injection can occur from any external input, not just http request input. You can be at risk if you use content read from a file, or from a web service, or from a function argument from other code, or the return value of other code, or even from your own database... trust nothing! :-)
You could make sure the column names themselves are escaped. Unfortunately, there is no built-in function to do that in most APIs or frameworks. So you'll have to do it yourself with regular expressions.
I also recommend you learn about PHP's builtin array functions (http://php.net/manual/en/ref.array.php). A lot of your code could be quicker to develop the code, and it will probably better runtime performance too.
Here's an example:
function quoteId($id) {
return '`' . str_replace($id, '`', '``') . '`';
}
$q = $pdo->query("SHOW COLUMNS FROM my_table");
while ($field = $q->fetchColumn()) {
$fields[] = $field;
}
$params = array_intersect_key($_POST, array_flip($fields));
$fieldList = implode(",", array_map("quoteId", array_keys($params)));
$placeholderList = implode(",", array_fill(1, count($params), "?"));
$sqlSub = "INSERT INTO other_table ($fieldList) VALUES ($placeholderList)";
$q = $pdo->prepare($sqlSub);
$q->execute($params);
In this example, I intersect the columns from the table with the post request parameters. This way I use only those post parameters that are also in the set of columns. It may end up producing an INSERT statement in SQL with fewer than all the columns, but if the missing columns have defaults or allow NULL, that's okay.

Answer 3

There is exactly one way to prevent SQL injection: to make sure that the text of your query-string never includes user-supplied content, no matter how you may attempt to 'sanitize' it.
When you use "placeholders," as suggested, the text of the SQL string contains (probably ...) question marks ... VALUES (?, ?, ?) to indicate each place where a parameter is to be inserted. A corresponding list of parameter values is supplied separately, each time the query is executed.
Therefore, even if value supplied for last_name is "tables; DROP TABLE STUDENTS;", SQL will never see this as being "part of the SQL string." It will simply insert that "most-unusual last_name" into the database.
If you are doing bulk operations, the fact that you need prepare the statement only once can save a considerable amount of time. You can then execute the statement as many times as you want to, passing a different (or, the same) set of parameter-values to it each time.