selecting data with laravel eloquent relationship - php

Question

I trying to understand laravel eloquent relationship so i created two tables. structure of tables defined in laravel migration is
for mostpopular table
Schema::create('mostpopulars',function(Blueprint $table){
$table->increments('id');
$table->integer('song_id')->unsigned();
$table->index('song_id');
$table->foreign('song_id')->references('id')->on('song_details')->delete('cascade');
});
for song_detail table
Schema::create('song_details', function (Blueprint $table) {
$table->increments('id');
$table->string('song_title');
$table->string('song_name');
$table->string('song_album');
$table->string('song_singer');
$table->string('song_musicby');
$table->string('song_location');
$table->string('song_album_image');
$table->string('song_language');
$table->string('song_lyrics',3000);
$table->timestamps();
});
then in Mostpopular model defined function for relating two table
public function song_detail()
{
return $this->hasOne('App\Song_detail','id');
}
and in controller index function i want to do something like this
$songs = Song_detail::select()->latest()->get();
$malayalamSongs = Mostpopular::select('song_id')->groupBy('song_id')->havingRaw('COUNT(*) > 2')->get();
$mp = $malayalamSongs;
dd($mp->song_detail);
but getting error
Undefined property: Illuminate\Database\Eloquent\Collection::$Song_detail
please help me to find the error and what i am trying to do is get the details of songs from song_details table where song_id occurred more than two times song_id is in mostpopular tables.

Answer 1

the eloquent get() will return an array, you cannot call relation method on the array.
you can use first() to replace the get() or
change
$mp = $malayalamSongs;
dd($mp->song_detail);
to
$mp = $malayalamSongs;
foreach($mp as $v)
{
dd($v->song_detail);
}