Replace all class instances with stub - php

Question

I am testing a class, let's call it ClassUnderTest using another class, let's call it OtherClass. In my Test I do:
$OtherClassStub = $this->createStub(OtherClass::class);
$OtherClassStub->method(...)
->willReturn(...);
$ClassUnderTest->otherClass = $OtherClassStub;
That works. But when the $ClassUnderTest calls new OtherClass(), the original OtherClass class is created instead of the stub.
How can I achieve that every possible instance of OtherClass in the context of the test is replaced by the stub?

Answer 1

From your description I infer that in principle you have something like this:
class OtherClass {
protected function someMethod(): bool
{
// determine $x ...
return $x;
}
}
class ClassUnderTest {
public OtherClass $otherClass;
public function methodToBeTested(): bool
{
$otherClass = new OtherClass();
return $otherClass->someMethod();
}
}
class ClassUnderTestTest extends TestCase {
public function testMethodToBeTested(): void
{
$otherClassStub = $this->createStub(OtherClass::class);
$otherClassStub->method('someMethod')
->willReturn(true);
$classUnderTest = new ClassUnderTest();
$classUnderTest->otherClass = $otherClassStub;
$result = $classUnderTest->methodToBeTested();
$this->assertTrue($result);
}
}
Now the assertion in your test may hold or it may fail. Why? Because you are not calling the method you stubbed on the $otherClassStub. Instead you instantiate a new $otherClass object in the method you're testing (or somewhere down the line).
Either your ClassUnderTest should always use the OtherClass object from the ClassUndertTest::otherClass attribute (assuming that's why you put it there in the first place).
Or you could use some other form of dependency injection, e.g. by using a framework like Symfony or Laravel. (In the case of Symfony you can even use only the DependencyInjection Component, no idea if that's possible with Laravel, too.)
The simple answer to your actual question is: you cannot change the behaviour of the new keyword. Calling new on a class will always instantiate a new object based on exactly that class, unless the constructor of that class defines something else.
(You might want to get the concept of classes and objects straight, your code example as well as your question seem to indicate that you're not quite clear on that. Maybe reading up on that as well as on the concept of dependency injection will help you.)

Answer 2

Perhaps a solution to your problem is presented here:
How to Build a PHP Plugin Module System
This is one way to load classes as plugins and they can be called from each other. With modifying this system a bit, you can create as many "new OtherClass()" as you like from your code and still access everything from other classes. If you want multiple instances of a class, perhaps modify it into this direction:
function load ($module,$instance) {
if (isset($this->$module->$instance)) { return true; }
From above link:
<?php
class Core {
// (A) PROPERTIES
public $error = ""; // LAST ERROR MESSAGE
public $pdo = null; // DATABASE CONNECTION
public $stmt = null; // SQL STATEMENT
public $lastID = null; // LAST INSERT/UPDATE ID
// (B) LOAD SPECIFIED MODULE
// $module : module to load
function load ($module) {
// (B1) CHECK IF MODULE IS ALREADY LOADED
if (isset($this->$module)) { return true; }
// (B2) EXTEND MODULE ON CORE OBJECT
$file = PATH_LIB . "LIB-$module.php";
if (file_exists($file)) {
require $file;
$this->$module = new $module();
// EVIL POINTER - ALLOW OBJECTS TO ACCESS EACH OTHER
$this->$module->core =& $this;
$this->$module->error =& $this->error;
$this->$module->pdo =& $this->pdo;
$this->$module->stmt =& $this->stmt;
return true;
} else {
$this->error = "$file not found!";
return false;
}
}
}
ps. thank you for the mod, who made me work a bit more to keep this answer online. the answer is so much better now.